UM-Dearborn logo

Amy Brainer interview

University of Michigan-Dearborn Oral Histories
Transcript
Toggle Index/Transcript View Switch.
Index
Search this Index
X
00:00:00 - Pathway to the director roles

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "Part of the purpose of my hire was to create the LGBTQ Studies program. There was already a team of people working on this in Women’s and Gender Studies. So while I became the first and so far the only program coordinator, I really was passed a baton. I’m grateful to the people who ran the first leg, or multiple legs for me, because they set me up for success with getting the program across the finish line."

Segment Synopsis: Amy Brainer, associate professor of Women's and Gender Studies, discusses how she became coordinator of LGBTQ studies and director of Women's and Gender Studies at the University of Michigan-Dearborn.

Keywords: Collaboration and/or Community; Integrating Research, Teaching, and Service; Legacy Maintenance; Program Sustainability; Academic Labor

00:04:00 - A transnational, queer, spiritual approach

Play segment

Partial Transcript: “I think if we want students to bring their whole selves, if we really want to practice intersectionality in our pedagogy, that has to include their spiritual selves.”

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses ways that her transnational and religious upbringing and her social location as a queer woman with a trans partner shape her work.

Keywords: Cultural Norms and Values; Intersections of Work, Life, and Family; Religious Identity and Practice; Sexual Politics; Student Diversity; Global and/or Transnational

00:08:11 - Building a rigorous program

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "I wanted to build a program that is truly rigorous. That to me means a program that is not narrowly focused on North America and what gender and sexuality mean in one place and at one time to one or a few groups of people. A big goal for me then and now is to give students real expertise in the field of LGBTQ studies... Students are a bridge between what we’re writing about in queer and transgender studies and what’s happening on the ground. We’re not doing armchair theorizing over here."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses what it means to build a rigorous program where students feel valued and well prepared for whatever comes next.

Keywords: Feminist Teaching and Learning; Global and/or Transnational; Integrating Research, Teaching, and Service; Feminist Theory and Praxis

00:11:32 - Equipping students for hard conversations

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "We don’t have to cancel people in our lives who ask us questions. Actually, we have very strong empirical data, and we have very strong reasoning, intellectual and moral reasoning, backing up our positions. From this position of strength, we can have empathy and we can build bridges to bring people in."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses the link between knowledge, reasoning, and the ability to tolerate hard conversations.

Keywords: Care Work and/or Emotion Work; Cultural Norms and Values; Feminist Teaching and Learning; Mentoring; Sexual Politics

00:14:58 - Expectations and commitments

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "As a younger queer person coming out in the early 2000s, I would never have imagined that so many straight people would care about this. That’s an adjustment of expectations in a really positive direction."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses her evolving expectations for the program and how she would like to be measured as a director.

Keywords: Collaboration and/or Community; Cultural Norms and Values; Leadership--Ethics and Approaches; Racial Politics; Sexual Politics

00:17:44 - Interpersonal care and administrative work

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "For Women’s and Gender Studies, which is a bigger program, there are a lot more administrative tasks. Tasks that I would describe as talking or writing about work, rather than actually doing the work. When I became the director, I found out that we have to spend a lot of time articulating who we are and justifying who we are... That sucks up a lot of time that I would like to spend doing other things."

Segment Synopsis: Amy describes the different types of labor her roles have entailed.

Keywords: Care Work and/or Emotion Work; Health--Mental, Emotional, Physical, Spiritual; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Integrating Research, Teaching, and Service; Academic Labor

00:21:09 - Burnout in the director role

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "For the first time, I did look at other jobs, non-academic jobs. Because I was like, if this is what academia is after tenure, it might not be for me. Before tenure, it was research and teaching. After tenure, I felt like I was just looking at this desert of service, service, service, service."

Segment Synopsis: Amy shares her experience of administrative burnout during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the support she received from colleagues that enabled her to heal.

Keywords: Alienation; COVID-19 Pandemic; Changing Technologies; Health--Mental, Emotional, Physical, Spiritual; Integrating Research, Teaching, and Service; Intersections of Work, Life, and Family; Academic Labor

00:25:27 - State violence and student protests

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "The students are the moral leaders in this struggle. And they’re also young, many of them. They need and deserve mentorship and support. We can’t just admire them from afar and talk about how excellent they are. We have to show them that we’re with them, that we’re standing with them. Our arms are linked. If they go to court, we go to court. If they challenge the regents, we challenge the regents."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses the political context of her directorships, including the criminalization of student protests against genocide in Gaza.

Keywords: Academic Freedom; Advocacy and/or Activism; Global and/or Transnational; Mentoring; Precarity; Racial Politics; Sexual Politics; State Violence

00:28:23 - Academic freedom

Play segment

Partial Transcript: “We had a Zoom meeting of WGST directors across Michigan... There were people from a lot of campuses, both public and private... Some people are actually in a position where their programs are closer to being dismantled. Some, like ours, are just sort of dealing in hypotheticals. Some maybe feel a little more protected than others.”

Segment Synopsis: Rose and Amy talk about recent attacks on so-called "DEI" [diversity, equity, and inclusion - but referring broadly to all emancipatory efforts and programs].

Keywords: Bias and Inequities; Budget and/or Austerity Measures; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Precarity; Program Sustainability; Racial Politics; Sexual Politics; Academic Freedom

00:32:07 - Responding to the world around us

Play segment

Partial Transcript: “Both queer studies and women’s studies have long histories of research, careful research, thorough research, by experts on Palestine. We can draw from that research, and we can anchor our actions in that knowledge.”

Segment Synopsis: Amy describes a variety of actions taken by the programs in response to events in and beyond the university.

Keywords: Academic Labor; Advocacy and/or Activism; Bias and Inequities; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Racial Politics; Academic Politics

00:39:13 - Respect and love for the students

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "They care about learning from each other. The LGBTQ and Women’s and Gender Studies students are sincere in this. They come in from wildly different backgrounds, and then in class they listen to each other, they talk to each other. I can see their openness, and I can see their growth."

Segment Synopsis: Amy describes the students in LGBTQ Studies as the best part of her job.

Keywords: Feminist Teaching and Learning; Feminist Theory and Praxis; Intersections of Work, Life, and Family; Religious Identity and Practice; Student Diversity

00:41:46 - Mentors, role models, and friends

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "If you want to grow intellectually, if you want to find people with a shared political consciousness, there are people here at Dearborn with a lot to offer. Sometimes I think, 'wow, how did we get so lucky to get this person,' you know? I still have that thought about some of the new faculty coming in."

Segment Synopsis: Amy describes some of the people who have mentored, inspired, and supported her at UM-Dearborn.

Keywords: Advocacy and/or Activism; Friendship; Invisible Labor; Mentoring; Promotion and Tenure; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld

00:47:27 - Staff precarity

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "The university does not pay staff a sustainable wage. It’s hard to have a family and a life on what they get paid. In this regard, we’re acting like staff are more expendable and replaceable, and like their skills matter less than those of faculty and administrators. I disagree with that. We’re a team. The person in that role matters. And for LGBTQ students and for my LGBTQ Studies program, continuity in that role matters."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses the precarity and consequent turnover of staff, and the ripple effects of this turnover for WGST and LGBTQ Studies.

Keywords: Academic Labor; Bias and Inequities; Budget and/or Austerity Measures; Program Sustainability; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld

00:50:23 - Losing the Include - a professional turning point

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "I really can’t explain how devastating this was for the students. I had students crying for months in my office. We did everything we could think of. We held a forum. We wrote a petition. I gathered students’ stories about the space and presented them. I got faculty to sign on to a letter asking the provost to restore our space or give us a new one... The students were asked to perform their grief over and over throughout this process, which was emotionally exhausting for them. The provost at the time was totally unmoved."

Segment Synopsis: Amy describes the abrupt loss of the Include, a space that was vitally important to trans and queer students on campus.

Keywords: Academic Politics; Advocacy and/or Activism; Budget and/or Austerity Measures; Care Work and/or Emotion Work; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Sexual Politics; Space and Proximity

00:55:44 - Queer kinship

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "Some of the things are related to being queer, and some are just related to life in general because maybe they are not close to adults in their life because of being queer. For example, a student would come and say hey, can you help me do my taxes? Doing taxes isn’t a queer thing. But being queer increases the chances that you don’t have an adult in your life who can help you do your taxes for the first time. And so you’re going to go to the adult you know and trust."

Segment Synopsis: Amy talks about her role as a queer adult in her students' lives beyond just being a professor.

Keywords: Care Work and/or Emotion Work; Collaboration and/or Community; Mentoring; Intersections of Work, Life, and Family

01:00:30 - Leadership and chronic illness

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "I’m not great at programming and event planning. My strengths are in relationships. I described it once in a text to you and Amny. I actually went back and found the text. I was describing what I sensed the students needed by way of mental health support at a particular moment in time. I wrote, 'They need someone to sit with them day in and day out in the Pride space and on WhatsApp listening to random conversations and laughing at their jokes. Then one day when they have a problem, you’re the safe person.'"

Segment Synopsis: Amy describes her leadership style as rooted in relationships and shaped by chronic illness.

Keywords: Care Work and/or Emotion Work; Collaboration and/or Community; Health--Mental, Emotional, Physical, Spiritual; Joy in the Work; Leadership--Ethics and Approaches

01:02:53 - Racial bias within Women's and Gender Studies

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "I’ve learned about great work that’s happening in different spaces, and I’ve learned about spaces where there are conflicts or even harm happening. I’ve seen for example, we’ve both seen, the classic problem of White feminism, where White women’s issues and White women themselves are elevated over women of color here at UM-Dearborn."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses the privileging of White women within WGST spaces.

Keywords: Academic Politics; Bias and Inequities; Colonial Feminism; Sexual Politics; Racial Politics

01:04:06 - Where we fit

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "Once again, we’re back in a place where we have to assert our right to exist and argue that something small is meaningful because it challenges the status quo. And that’s what a rigorous education should do."

Segment Synopsis: Amy discusses the value of small programs that challenge the status quo, and their unintelligibility in the current climate.

Keywords: Budget and/or Austerity Measures; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Interdisciplinarity; Invisible Labor; Neoliberalism; Program Visibility Strategies; Academic Politics

01:06:10 - Cherished memories of student growth

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "I had a table where I was telling people about LGBTQ Studies, and I had brought LGBTQ Studies books. One of them was Ghassan Moussawi’s book Fractal Orientalism and Queer Strategies in Beirut. A student who had never taken any LGBTQ Studies courses saw it and said, 'Sounds complicated.' And I sort of chuckled because you know, yeah. A few minutes later another student came up who is similar in many ways to the first in their background. I knew them both pretty well, so I knew about these similarities. The second student was about three classes deep in the program. And they picked up the same book, and they said, 'Ooh, interesting.' And I just felt this swell of joy inside. I was like, that’s LGBTQ Studies. It opened this door."

Segment Synopsis: Amy shares memories of students growing as scholars and as people.

Keywords: Collaboration and/or Community; Joy in the Work; Student Diversity; Feminist Teaching and Learning

01:09:02 - Advice and hopes for future directors

Play segment

Partial Transcript: “It can be overwhelming when we feel like we have to fill someone else’s shoes. But all these directors brought their own shoes, right? We’re unique. We’re strong in different ways. And then speaking to future directors: chances are, people are more proud of you than you realize.”

Segment Synopsis: Amy shares advice and hopes for LGBTQ Studies and Women’s and Gender Studies, while acknowledging the precarity and uncertainty these programs, faculty, and students are facing.

Keywords: Academic Freedom; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Leadership--Ethics and Approaches; Legacy Maintenance; Precarity; Program Sustainability; Budget and/or Austerity Measures

01:12:51 - Conclusion: with and without a space

Play segment

Partial Transcript: "Without a space, there was not the cohesion, the friendships and things, because we’re a commuter campus... It can’t just be, oh I saw you at an event. We’re all too socially awkward to meet people at events. [Laughter] That’s just not how we’re going to make a community."

Segment Synopsis: Rose and Amy wrap up the interview by reiterating the importance of having a space for LGBTQ students on campus.

Keywords: Academic Freedom; Collaboration and/or Community; Friendship; Institutional Support--Received or Withheld; Precarity; Space and Proximity